Law Firm & Life

Dispatches from a Panel on Copyright Law

By Emily Poler

Last week, I moderated a panel discussion titled Litigation Update on the Music Front, at the New York State Bar Association’s Entertainment, Arts & Sports Law Section Fall Meeting 2026, Music Business and Law Conference (That’s a mouthful, eh?). It was my first time moderating a panel like this and stay tuned, because I’m going to try to do this more. 

Our four illustrious panelists analyzed developments and decisions in high profile cases with implications for copyright infringement cases across all media. I’ve written about some of these here before, and it was fascinating to hear other attorneys’ perspectives on these very significant lawsuits. Here are some highlights (Alert: It’s longer than my usual posts, but I’d like to think it’s worth a few extra minutes reading time) 

Lindsay Korotkin of ArentFox Schiff LLP started the panel off with a look at the Supreme Court’s 9-0 decision in Cox Communications, Inc. v. Sony Music Entertainment, which reversed a $1 billion verdict against Cox for the internet service provider’s failure to prevent subscribers from sharing pirated copies of Sony-owned media over Cox’s network. Lindsay explained how SCOTUS’ decision will significantly limit copyright owner’s ability to hold ISPs liable for contributory negligence. According to Korotkin, the only way an ISP can be found liable is if it “intended that its service be used for infringement,” she said. “One of the big takeaways is paying attention to how things are being marketed and advertised,” as in the current Disney Enterprises, Inc. et al. v. MiniMax et al, (which I wrote about here), where MiniMax’s Hailuo AI video generator was advertised with images of copyrighted characters and the tagline “A Hollywood Studio in Your Pocket.” 

Next, Joshua Graubart of Spencer West discussed Vetter vs. Resnik, a dispute between a songwriter and the company that owned some of his music publishing. The lower court’s opinion in favor of the plaintiff, which the Fifth Circuit affirmed, “shocked a lot of people,” Graubart said. Long story short, the District Court and the Fifth Circuit concluded that an artist exercising termination rights (which you can find out more about here) in the US extends worldwide because all of that artist’s copyrights flow from the US rights. That’s the shocking part because until this case almost everyone assumed that termination rights only applied domestically. For now, the Fifth Circuit’s decision is going to stand because the Supreme Court declined to take the case. Why? Apparently because four justices recused themselves, leaving SCOTUS without a quorum. The four justices didn’t explain their motives, but Graubart says the leading theory is that all have publishing contracts with Penguin Random House, a sister company of BMG. And thus, Graubart asks, “can BMG go to the Supreme Court on anything?”

Remember the Kat Von D case (if you don’t, fear not, you can catch up here)? That’s where photographer Jeff Sedlik sued the celebrity tattoo artist over inking a dupe of his portrait of Miles Davis on a friend’s arm while posting the process on Instagram. Our panel’s Nancy Wolff of Cowan DeBacts, Abrahams and Sheppard LLP covered that one, in which the District Court denied Sedlik’s motion for summary judgment and the jury found against him, concluding the works weren’t similar in their overall “total concept and feel” (the so-called “intrinsic test”). This seemed crazy to anyone who looked at the two images! “There’s complete unpredictability with the intrinsic tests,” said Wolff, which she explained often are based on a jury’s emotions: “It could have been that they thought [Sedlik] was maybe annoying, and [Kat Von D] was a really cool celebrity tattoo artist, and they didn’t want her to be sued. And then to make it worse, it’s completely unreviewable.” Which is one reason why summary judgment, in which a judge presumably takes a more common sense view, is so critical to creators. Another reason: “If you generally can’t win on summary judgment, a case will settle because it is just so expensive to have a jury trial,” Wolff said. Sedlik subsequently appealed the summary judgment denial before the Ninth Circuit, but that Court’s three-judge panel declined to review. And so Sedlik appealed for an en banc review, a rare event in which all 11 Ninth Circuit judges considered his case in September. 

Last, but certainly not least, Felicity Kohn of Pryor Cashman, took on the case of Allen v. Perlmutter, which I wrote about here. To me, this was the most interesting case of the day. In summary, Jason Allen created an image in Midjourney AI and the US Copyright Office denied his attempt to register a copyright in that work, finding it lacked the “traditional elements of authorship” because Allen was basically contributing ideas (not protectable), and did not control “expression” of the final work (protectable). Kohn talked about how after reading Allen’s brief, in which he described how he selected the scene, the elements, and the tone, and then refined the generated image over 600 times to get the output he wanted, she felt there was enough human intervention to qualify for copyright protection. But then Kohn read the US Copyright Office’s brief, and was surprised to have her mind changed. (I had the same reaction!) “Although he honestly revised the image using Photoshop and upscaling software,” Kohn said, “the Midjourney output indisputably remained part of the work.” Kohn was especially impressed by an example the Copyright Office pointed to, where the prompt “white bunny with low ears, rainbow background, love, cute, happy” produced four entirely different looking bunnies (and only one with low ears), illustrating, in Kohn’s opinion, “how much of this comes from Midjourney and not from Allen. If the same prompt can result in such vastly differing expressions, the prompter then can’t be the one to translate the idea into expression. And that’s why he can’t be the author.”

What I Saw in You Can See Everything

By Emily Poler

Alert! If you plan to watch You Can See Everything, the documentary about disgraced entrepreneur Elizabeth Holmes and haven’t yet, some very mild spoilers ahead. Otherwise, read on.

In case you’ve missed the cultural hoopla, the film crew basically moved into the house Holmes shared with her partner, Billy Evans, and their children for the month before Holmes went to prison for defrauding investors in Theranos. (If you’ve forgotten, Theranos was a mult-billion dollar health technology company founded by Holmes. She claimed the company invented a revolutionary mechanism for performing blood tests. However, it was all a bunch of B.S., she was convicted of fraud, and sentenced to 11 years in prison.)

There were sooooo many interesting things about the doc! It focuses on Holmes’ world and her relationship with Evans just before going behind bars in May, 2023, and follows up two years later while she’s doing time and Evans is raising their two kids. But the film is also about the relationship between documentary film crews and their subjects, what’s truth and what’s a lie, and, most fascinating, how people’s minds work.

Is talking about a documentary an unusual topic for this blog? I suppose so, but there are a couple of legal, or at least legally adjacent elements to it, that I think are worth discussing. Plus, it’s my blog!

So first off, unlike many documentary films where the crew is unseen or appears only as a disembodied voice asking questions of the subject, the crew here and co-director Nathan Fielder, are very, very present throughout. As a lawyer, I found Fielder’s manner fascinating. He frequently would ask Holmes or Evans questions and, after they finished answering, Fielder would say nothing. Eventually Holmes or Evans would start to talk again with both, and Evans in particular, revealing more than was in the initial answer. 

This tactic is similar to something I and many other litigators do in depositions. We ask a question, get an answer, and then pause. There are a couple of reasons for this but a big one is that most people are uncomfortable with silence and when faced with it, they will start babbling. As in You Can See Everything, leaving awkward silences can lead to getting your best information.

Also, Fielder spoke in a completely deadpan, cool manner, as if he had no idea his difficult or embarrassing questions might make the subject uncomfortable. Again, this is really similar to what many litigators do in depositions. When questioning a witness, I need to get a great deal of information, much of which is banal, but some of which the witness might not want to divulge. So I need to dispassionately ask questions that get the easy answers while also not tipping the witness off to where I’m going in quest of the hard stuff. I also can’t show any emotion when he or she divulges something that’s great for my client’s case (or display my frustration when the witness is less than truthful). Those “gotcha” moments are, of course, critical to the process, but while I get the sense that a lot of non-lawyers (and maybe some lawyers who aren’t litigators) think litigation is just a series of “gotcha” moments, it’s really not (at least for me). They’re one piece of the overall gathering of necessary data. 

If you watch the movie, you’ll see Fielder did a great job using those techniques to draw unexpected revelations from Holmes and Evans, which is a big part of why the doc is so amazing and it seems like everybody is talking about it right now. 

Finally, a question for any criminal defense attorneys out there: How does the law handle profits generated by a book or film for people who have been convicted of crimes when they participate in the production? I don’t want to go into too much detail here, but part of the film delves into whether Holmes or her partner, Evans, will make money from the doc, which has already grossed $45 million in the two weeks since release. Given that Holmes owes millions of dollars in restitution, is there any chance that she would ever receive that money or would it go (relatively) straight to her victims? 

If anyone has any idea, can you let me know?

Litigation Doesn’t Mean Table Pounding

By Emily Poler

Labor Day has come and gone, commercials for Starbucks Pumpkin Spice Latté (blech) are flooding the streaming platforms, and all those fresh-faced (for now) first-year associate attorneys are marching off to their new lives. Which puts me in mind of my early days in the legal arena, and specifically, the first trial I ever participated in. Well really, it was an arbitration hearing in a conference room, not a courtroom, but close enough to the real thing for young me. I was a super junior lawyer, a year or so out of law school, and it was just me and one of my firm’s partners representing our side. A lot of what went down was well above my pay grade, but I could work a photocopier and put papers into folders, so that was pretty much my role. Nonetheless, there were a bunch of things that day that have stuck with me. 

Our client’s only witness was a woman. As the hearing went on, every time my colleague was concerned about what she might say or how well she was prepared to testify on a particular topic, he would send me and her to the ladies room. Why? Because we were literally the only two people using it so there was absolutely zero risk of anyone overhearing our potentially privileged conversations. Cone of silence! I suppose nowadays some might cry sexism (“they made you act like girls at a nightclub going to fix your makeup together!”), but it made sense at the time and worked perfectly.

More to the point of this post, however, I was  amazed by the way my colleague just absolutely badgered the other side’s lead witness. At one moment the witness even swiveled his chair, turning his back for a temporary respite from the brutal cross-examination. (The arbitrator in the room exercised absolutely no control over the proceedings; he definitely dozed more than once during the hearing.) The other side must have had counsel, but I remember absolutely nothing about him or her and have no recollection of any effort to try to stop our side’s super aggressive questioning. 

At the time, I was shocked at my colleague’s performance (and it was most assuredly a performance). I also remember thinking that, particularly as a young woman, there was absolutely no way in a million years I would ever be able to treat a witness like that. 

Such lawyerly steamrolling comes to mind as a result of some recent dealings I’ve had with opposing counsel. In one case, the attorney was insistent that we have discussions on the phone, with the clients joining. I agreed to it — once. On that first call it immediately became clear that what opposing counsel really wanted was to go around me and speak directly to my client. That call ended VERY quickly. Since then, all calls have been without clients and I’ve been very careful to send him notes in follow-up emails. My reward? He has made it clear he thinks I’m out of my mind for refusing to have our clients talk to him, and for daring to memorialize our discussions in writing. Fine, he can be as aggressive as he likes, such behavior has no effect on me anymore. I’m doing what I know is right for my clients and myself.

Flipping the situation, in another case the opposing firm has, for better or worse, put the proceedings in the hands of a very, VERY junior lawyer without much of a clue. Now, I could be an absolute jerk to her because she would have no idea of how to respond. An easy win and power move for me, right? But obviously I’m not going to beat her down because that’s not my game. I know I can get what I need for my client without torturing opposing counsel, nor do I need to fuel my ego by performing like a gladiator — a need that seems to drive too many in my profession.

All these thoughts boil down to the simple tenet that just because your opposing counsel is doing something in a particular way, you don’t have to do it that way. Nor should a client expect — or want — their attorney to be overly antagonistic when it does nothing to advance the cause (even if it can make for entertaining theater).

A Midsummer Day’s Blog Post

By Emily Poler

It’s the middle of summer and, as much as I love writing this blog, right now I’d rather go lie in the shade and finish my book. All of which is to say, this week is going to be a short roundup of a few things that have caught my eye, and then I’m getting back to reading. It’s my All-Star break!

First off, because it’s summer, let’s talk about ice cream. A federal district judge directed ice cream maker Rebel Creamery to pay Van Leeuwen Ice Cream more than $20 million, finding Rebel duplicated the look of Van Leeuwen’s minimalist ice cream containers. The judge also directed Rebel to use packaging that wasn’t going to confuse consumers. (As an aside, it’s still hard to believe that Van Leeuwen started in a NYC food truck not that long ago, then opened a tiny storefront in Greenpoint, and now you can buy their flavors in bodegas, gas stations, supermarkets, and their own stores pretty much anywhere in America. That’s a whole lot of Cookies & Cream).

Next: Last week, the companies that own and operate Madison Square Garden sued Wired and one of its authors over an article titled “Madison Square Garden Kept a List of Gay Celebrities,” which, according to the plaintiffs, created a misleading impression that they keep such information to “discriminate against LGBTQIA celebrities, artists, guests, fans, and patrons because of their sexual orientation or gender identity . . . .” For what it’s worth, I read the Wired article, and that wasn’t the impression I took away from it. Still, it’s caused a bit of a furor, adding to the never-ending season of MSG in the news (Knicks in 5!). 

And finally, on July 1 a federal district court judge denied motions for summary judgment in a lawsuit over whether a particular rhythm at the basis of the reggaeton genre is sufficiently original to be copyrightable. This means that the case will now go to a jury that will have to figure out if almost 2,000 tracks by artists including Bad Bunny, Pitbull, Drake, and Justin Bieber infringe on the “dembow riddim” created by Jamaican dancehall producers Cleveland Browne and Wycliffe Johnson (aka Steely & Clevie) in their 1989 track “Fish Market.” Defendants argue that the rhythm is part of an ancient musical tradition and not a unique creation, and thus belongs to the public domain. Bad Bunny has already asked the court to reconsider its decision here.

See you in August (where, oh where, did July go?)!

Truth and Justice on the Verge of a Nervous Breakdown

By Emily Poler

A couple of weeks ago I started to write this post about the latest Serial podcast, which is titled The Idiot and narrated by New York Times opinion columnist M. Gessen. My aim was to use the story of Gessen’s cousin Allen, who was convicted of ordering a hit on his ex-wife, as a jumping-off point for talking about getting clients to face hard truths. I couldn’t quite finish what I was writing though; something just didn’t feel right. 

As I sat on it, I listened to a discussion of prediction markets — platforms where participants can buy and sell shares based on their beliefs of the outcomes of future events — and whether these markets will be significantly regulated by the federal government (my prediction: no). While mulling that over, I realized what I wanted to write about was actually truth, justice, and the “American Way.” Or at least the values and rules that have traditionally underpinned those ideals. 

As anyone who reads this blog with any regularity knows, I’m a litigator. That means I have regular interactions with the courts. It also means I spend a lot of time thinking about what’s fair and, while I don’t use this word in daily parlance, what’s just.

I’ve been pondering this a lot more lately because, simply put, it feels like the wheels are coming off the bus. Increasingly, attorneys and their clients are behaving badly, flouting court rules, pursuing arguments that contradict established precedent, and prosecuting opponents with accusations so bizarre and trivial as to seem insane. (If a client tries to involve me in anything like this, I tell them they need to find another lawyer.) Thankfully, in many cases judges and juries continue to do great work rejecting and even condemning such actions. 

Or maybe it just seems like things are going in the wrong direction because of a certain person with a very loud megaphone who is pushing, for example, the second prosecution of former FBI Director James Comey for posting a photo on Instagram of the numbers “86 47” spelled out in seashells that he saw on a beach; the Trump administration claims that constitutes a threat against the president. Is it a coincidence that Comey led the initial investigation into Trump’s alleged collusion with Russia during the 2016 election? 

The problem here is that as established rules are attacked and perverted, people start to believe that not only can they get away with anything, but that they are right to do so. Everybody else is doing it, so why not me? Look at the case of the Fort Bragg soldier who was involved in the planning of the U.S. military operation to capture Venezuelan president Nicolás Maduro, and allegedly used his (obviously) classified information to bet on its timing in a prediction market and profit to the tune of more than $400,000. 

And, circling back to The Idiot podcast, M. Gessen’s cousin Allen continues to vigorously deny hiring an assassin through an intermediary (actually an undercover FBI agent) to murder his ex-wife despite overwhelming evidence, including recordings of the hiring discussions, that that’s exactly what he did. Why do these people think they can get away with these illegal, immoral and disgusting actions? Because they believe they’re right to do so. That’s what we call delusion, a condition that seems to be on the rise and that no pharmaceutical company can create a drug to combat. 

Getting back to what I’ve seen happening in courtrooms over the past few years, I’m not decrying lawyers advocating zealously on behalf of their clients, which we’re all supposed to do. Nor am I condemning attorneys for sometimes missing a deadline or making an honest oversight. What I’m talking about are people playing really fast and loose with the law or the facts. 

This has always bothered me. I have a pretty strong sense of what’s right and what’s wrong, and I find it upsetting when people aren’t treated fairly and don’t behave toward others in a way that is equitable. And, while I certainly understand and acknowledge that there are often grey areas, I think (or I’d like to think) that most lawyers are also motivated, at least in part, by the idea of making sure things are fair. Now, though, when we’re barraged with pretty much daily examples of people and attorneys flouting the rules in really grotesque ways, I’m more troubled than ever.  

Do these little transgressions matter? YES. In some ways, the legal system is a giant trust exercise, kind of like crossing the street in midtown. It only works because cars don’t go when there is a red light. In the case of the court system, it means you follow the rules: When you lose a case, you pay the amount the court says you owe, or when a court tells you to do something, you don’t do something else (or nothing at all). If rules and rulings are ignored, the system will slowly start to break down, and eventually stop working entirely. And while the consequences of that would be significant for an individual attorney like me, that’s nothing compared to what it will do to our society and every person in it. 

That’s today’s rant. I’m curious to know if other attorneys have similar feelings (I can’t believe it’s just me). Let me know what you think!